Which ariel powder is better. Warning - toxic! Ariel test results.

Good hostess always looking for himself best options funds household chemicals so that there are savings and the tool fully performs its functions. Among a large assortment advertised washing powders are difficult to make right away right choice and determine which powder is better - Ariel or Persil? In this article, we will try to sort through the benefits of the most popular laundry detergents and help you choose a really high-quality powder.

How to choose washing powder?

Internet forums and blogs are full of information about the results of the hostesses' own experience. Among so many opinions, it is difficult to determine which of them is the most objective and which one is really worth listening to. To back up the words with arguments, we present the results of real testing. So it will be easier for you to decide which powder is better - Ariel or Persil.

Which powder is better - Ariel or Persil?

As they say in advertising, the powder copes with any pollution, even the most persistent. Do well-known powders really remove such stubborn dirt as lipstick, mascara, foundation and ketchup?

persil automaton

With careful selection detergent it is necessary to take into account its indicated by the manufacturer component composition and real cleaning properties.

Composition:

• This powder does not belong to safe phosphate-free products, which the manufacturer honestly indicated on the powder packaging. But it should be noted that, nevertheless, phosphonates are used to soften water, which are less harmful than phosphates that are part of other products.
• The amount of anionic surfactants unsafe for the human body is 5-15%.

Important! The optimal content of surfactants in the washing powder is 5-7%.

• The list of active ingredients of the product also includes an optical brightener, which is not completely washed out of clothes and harms our skin. In fact, it does not whiten, but simply creates an “optical” effect of whiteness, thanks to luminescent particles deposited on the surface of the fabric.

Important! For real washing and whitening the fabric, manufacturers use oxygen bleach, which is not included in this washing powder.

• The fragrance of washing powder has enough pleasant aroma and leaves on clothes only slight smell, which is easy to drown out with your perfume.

Washing properties

So, how does this tool cope with the removal of the above stains in a normal wash with a water temperature of 40 degrees? – We make an assessment based on practical notes and experience:

• The ketchup washed off completely, leaving no trace behind.
• The mascara left a light mark, but did not completely wash off.
• Lipstick only slightly changed shade to a lighter one.
• The tonal cream remained practically unchanged.

Important! It is unlikely that you will ever soil your clothes in such a quantity and so “generously” in this way, so consider the intensity of possible contamination.

It is worth noting that after subsequent washes, the stains from lipstick and mascara still disappeared, but the greasy layer of foundation without bleach could not be removed.

Washing powder Ariel

This powder in its composition is a bit similar to the already described Persil. Will its properties differ in order to understand which powder is better - Ariel or Persil?

Composition:

• 5-15% anionic surfactants.
• harmful phosphates.
• There is no optical brightener in the composition of the powder.
• Zeolites are used as washing aids, the harm or harmlessness of which is constantly discussed. The negative point of such components is their poor ability to rinse out, damage to fabrics and parts of washing machines. They also lead to the “dustiness” of the washing powder.

Important! When you open a new pack of Ariel laundry detergent, you will immediately see and feel the dust particles that quickly spread around the room. Such an action can lead to clogging of the respiratory tract and affect the well-being of allergy sufferers.

• The powder has an intense pungent odor that stays on the washed clothes for a long time.

Washing properties

As for the “direct duties” of the powder, it coped in the same washing mode in almost the same way as the previous tested product:

Outcome

Based on the testing, you can conclude for yourself which powder is better - Ariel or Persil. They wash almost the same, the composition is unsafe, but as for the smell, Ariel has a more intense and sharp aroma. For some, this is a significant disadvantage, but there are many people for whom this characteristic is only the advantage of the detergent.

Which powder is better - Ariel or Tide?

Another famous washing powder, for the advertising of which the manufacturer did not spare money, is Tide. What are its characteristics and can it really replace the proven boiling, as TV commercials assure? Are the washing properties of Tide different from the already proven Ariel or Persil?

For a more objective assessment of powders, we will create the same “working conditions” for them.

Test task:

Remove coffee, blood, tomato, grass and wine stains from white terry towels.

Test conditions:

1. Quick wash mode in the washing machine cold water for 25 minutes.
2. Full cycle washing in water at a temperature of 60 degrees for 65 minutes.

Ariel test results:

1. Fast cycle. In cold water, the powder did an excellent job of removing grass and tomato stains and lightly removed coffee stains. Traces of wine and blood remained virtually unchanged.
2. Full cycle. All stains were completely removed from the fabric.

Tide test results:

Persil test results:

1. Quick wash. When interacting with cold water the powder managed to completely remove traces of tomato and grass from the terry towel, the coffee stain became barely noticeable. Wine and blood remained virtually unchanged.
2. Full wash. All impurities completely disappeared from the white matter.

Test result

All three powders, which have brought considerable fame to advertising, cope with washing stubborn stains in almost the same way, without having a miraculous effect in cold water and perfectly coping with problems in hot. Therefore, you will still have to decide which powder is better - Ariel or Tide or Persil, according to the criterion of price and personal preferences.

The next time you are going to the store for washing powder, consider the information provided in the article. If you have small children, then for safety reasons we do not recommend that you use these products, since their composition is far from the permissible composition of detergents for washing things for newborns and older children. To make sure that your actions do not harm the health of the baby, use soap nuts during washing or phosphate-free powders marked “hypoallergenic” or “for washing baby clothes”.

"Are you still boiling laundry? - the nightingale is filled with another advertisement. - Then we are going to you!"

What, or rather, who to believe - after all, advertising has long grown into a kind of struggle between images and characters? A popular actor, the hero of Chukovsky's poem or a famous TV presenter? My friends have repeatedly started an argument about which is better - "Tide" or "Ariel". After another discussion, it became interesting for me to see if these washing powders differ at all? To do this, I took some of the most popular brands today - Ariel, Tide, Dosia, Losk, Persil and Mif.

The test was carried out using the same automatic washing machine with two modes:
1. Quick wash in cold water (25 minutes);
2. Full wash cycle at 60°C (65 minutes).
Whites were taken as "guinea pigs" terry towels, on which five types of pollution are applied: coffee, blood (meat), stains from grass and tomatoes, wine stains.

ARIEL
Quick wash. When washing in cold water, the powder perfectly removed stains from tomatoes and grass, the coffee stain turned pale, but still remained, the powder did not cope with wine and blood.
Full wash.

TIDE
Quick wash. Like the Ariel wash, the wine and meat stains didn't come off, and the coffee stain only faded slightly. Not a trace of tomato and grass stains remained.
Full wash. Not a single stain remained.

DOSIA
Quick wash. Just like the previous two, the powder removed grass and tomato stains, and also managed to cope with a coffee stain. But he couldn't do anything about blood and wine.
Full wash. Not a single stain remained.

LOSK
Quick wash. The powder coped with stains from grass and tomatoes, but was powerless against coffee, blood and wine stains.
Full wash. There was a wine stain (barely noticeable).

"MYTH"
Quick wash. This tool perfectly cleaned the stains from grass and tomatoes. The powder did not do so well with coffee - the stain only faded. But the wine and blood remained in place.
Full wash. Not a single stain remained.

PERSIL
Quick wash. When washing in cold water, the powder removed stains from tomatoes and grass, the coffee stain was almost imperceptible, and the powder did not cope with wine and blood.
Full wash. Not a single stain remained.

Clean clothes are not only a matter of impression and reputation, but primarily a matter of health. To ensure high-quality cleaning of linen, it is important to choose suitable remedy to remove contaminants. Finding out which powder washes well is not easy in today's variety. It is necessary to understand the composition of the products offered, the properties of their main active components and the level of safety for humans. We will discuss these issues in more detail in this article.

Types of laundry detergents

The main mistake of housewives is that many tend to use the same product for any type of laundry when they find out which powder washes well. It should be ideal for a certain type of fabric. So, if a product that is intended for hand washing turned out to be effective, you should not try to use it for an automatic one. Used for other purposes, the powder will not fully show its properties, and the laundry will not be cleaned well. Such products contain a large amount of substances that form a lush foam, which is not needed in this case.

What types of washing powders exist today? As a rule, the classification is carried out according to the types of tissues for which this or that remedy is intended. According to this criterion, powders are divided into universal (intended for all types of fabric), for synthetics, wool, as well as linen and cotton materials. However, the price is not critical.

So, if you are planning a large-scale wash, and all things are made of the same material (say, cotton), it is better to use a cheaper product, but a highly specialized one.

Powder composition

Before making a choice effective remedy, you need to understand the purpose of the individual components that make up a particular product. You should be especially careful if there are children or people who suffer from allergies in the house.

Main active ingredient, which is invariably included in the composition of any washing powder, are surfactants, or so-called surfactants, designed to effectively separate dirt from the surface of any texture. Their classification contains three types, namely: cationic, anionic and non-ionic.

The danger is the anionic type, which is indicated in the composition as A-surfactant. Such substances cause a variety of allergic reactions, manifested, for example, by a rash on human skin, and also drastically reduce the efficiency of the immune system.

Any surfactants have an extremely negative impact on the environment and the human body. Therefore, rinsing clothes is such an important process, because it is during it that all dangerous components are removed from the surface of the fabric. Do not save, it is better to rinse things again by running the appropriate program.

According to experts, a truly high-quality laundry detergent cannot contain more than five percent of surfactants.

Why are enzymes needed?

Enzymes are often positioned in commercials as a panacea, substances that are essential for successful washing. Allegedly, their presence or absence determines which powder washes well. And, in a way, it is. Enzymes are biologically active substances that are used to effectively remove stains, especially grease, which are considered the most difficult.

However, these components can also harm some delicate tissues, so powders that contain them should be used with caution.

What are phosphates?

Phosphates are an effective mix of metals and acids, which noticeably soften water during washing, prevent the formation of scale, which contributes to a more successful process of removing dirt.

What is characteristic: all cleaning products produced in Western countries do not contain the mentioned components, since these substances actively provoke the occurrence of allergic reactions associated with both the skin and the respiratory tract. In many states, their use is prohibited at the legislative level.

These substances are replaced by zeolites, which do not cause any harm to either the environment or human health. Powders of this kind, as a rule, are labeled "phosphate-fried".

Determine the type of whitening

Sometimes exclusively challenging task it becomes necessary to choose a washing powder for white linen. It is important to know that there are two types of fabric bleaching. You can understand which of them a particular washing powder is intended for by carefully reading the composition of the latter. So, if it contains any kind of peroxide salts, then the product is an ordinary chemical bleach, and if the substances included in the composition have a formula starting with "C", it is optical. What this means in practice, we will consider further.

Can ordinary powder bleach clothes

In order to ensure a quality result, it would be preferable to use a 2 in 1 detergent. Such powders are either of the first or second type of bleaches described above. Next, we will talk in more detail about each of them.

So, chemical bleach is a product based on bleach or peroxide. Such a powder actively destroys the color of the fabric and is not suitable for delicate materials. But oxygen bleach spares the fabric. It can be used for any clothes, including colored ones.

Optical brightener does not destroy the fabric and its overall color, but effectively masks any stains. This is due to the unique reflective particles that make up its composition.

Which powder washes well - chemical or optical brightener? As a rule, they both can become effective, and their main difference is the cost of packaging.

Choosing a powder that is designed for baby clothes

The presence of a child in the home requires the use of suitable cleaning products and washing powders. And this is not just the intrigues of marketers! The composition of products intended for children is really different from that for adults. The components of children's powders have a much more gentle effect on the young body. Their use is also recommended for allergy sufferers.

The most undesirable components are different kind bleach and soda. To verify this, it is important to carefully study the composition of the product.

It is appropriate to recall that familiar to many housewives laundry soap is not safe for babies. Great amount alkali, which is part of it, has a negative effect on the skin of the child. And it is not able to remove stains by far.

How to choose a quality powder?

In order to choose a truly effective and safe remedy, when buying a powder, it is important to pay attention to the following nuances. References to the absence of toxins are usually true, so they should be noted. It is also necessary to control the percentage of substances that make up the product (no more than five percent for surfactants and no more than twelve for phosphates). It would be more profitable to purchase not one universal powder for all types of fabrics, but several specialized ones. It is also desirable to have different means for colored and white clothes, children's (for families with babies) and enzyme stain remover. It is important to use products specially designed for this purpose for both hand washing and automatic washing.

It is necessary to remember the proportion of the means used. For every kilogram of laundry intended for washing, there should be about one tablespoon of powder. Its deficiency will lead to poor cleaning, and its excess will lead to a persistent pungent odor and the presence of chemical particles on the fabric.

Powder "Persil"

One of the most popular laundry detergents is Persil. Liquid powder is positioned as an effective agent for cleaning both white and colored things (depending on the purpose of a particular product, however, there are also universal substances in the product line). It contains enzymes, which means it is able to remove a variety of stains, including traces of berries and any drinks (even red wine). However, these components remain active only during the powder's shelf life, which is three years. After its expiration, the properties of the product as a stain remover are lost, however, it remains suitable for washing in general. Also, in order for the product to retain its properties, it is important to store it at a temperature not exceeding thirty-five degrees Celsius.

As well as funds of any other brand, should not be stored together with any food products or in a place accessible to children. If the product gets on the mucous membranes, they must be washed big amount pure water.

Powder "Tide"

Tide powders are produced by a well-known American manufacturer chemicals Procter & Gamble, which in itself is a guarantee of quality. The product has established itself as the undisputed leader in the laundry industry. The components of the product do not damage the fabric structure and at the same time effectively eliminate stains of any complexity. And the popular representative of the line - Tide Color - contributes to the preservation of color intensity. In addition, this powder also acts as a fragrance for linen.

Important: Tide powder (automatic) does not contain phosphates, instead of them, safe zeolites are included. Also, the active components of the product are enzymes that effectively fight stains. At the same time, the content of anionic surfactants slightly exceeds the allowed five percent.

Powder "Eared nannies"

This product is designed specifically for washing baby clothes. It can be used even if we are talking about the things of a newborn. "Eared nannies" is positioned as a hypoallergenic remedy. The line includes products designed for both manual and automatic washing. According to the manufacturer, the structure of the product is such that it is easily rinsed out of the tissues, so its particles do not linger in the fibers and do not irritate the baby's skin.

In order for the powder not to lose its properties, it should be the right way store (in a dark cool place).

Despite the fact that the product is intended specifically for children's clothes, it contains phosphates and a significant amount of A-surfactants (from five to fifteen percent), which can have a negative effect on the skin.

Powder "Ariel"

Another famous brand is Ariel. The powder of this brand contains enzymes, effective system combinations of surfactants. The structure of the product is such that it is able to effectively clean tissues even at low temperatures (forty degrees). Mountain spring" implements oxygen-containing whitening, and also creates the effect of optical whitening. This provides an amazing result.

Summary

After analyzing all the above information about laundry detergents and considering the compositions of popular powders, we can draw the following conclusions. If you want to purchase a product that would protect your child from the negative effects of chemicals, you should not spend money on a product called "Eared Nanny". This powder is effective on its own, but its composition is no different from other, "adult" substances. So, for example, "Tide", by and large, is much safer, since, unlike "Eared Nanny", it does not contain harmful phosphates that can contribute to allergic reactions. Procter & Gamble powder replaces them with safe zeolites that won't harm baby's delicate skin. "Persil" is extremely effective for removing all kinds of stains due to the significant content of enzymes in it. It is useful to have this tool at home in order to cope with serious pollution in time. However, it is not the most effective if the hostess is faced with the task of bleaching linen. In this regard, Ariel is in the lead - a powder that provides high-quality cleansing of tissues. Moreover, during the bleaching process, "Ariel" does not damage the fibers of the fabric, does not destroy their structure, but acts only directly on the stain.

Cleanliness largely determines your health. Always make your choice wisely!

Russia annually produces 1 million tons of washing powder. More than 80% of the powders are detergents for washing in automatic machines. Are modern washing powders safe for consumer health? Which powder does the job better than others?

Roskontrol.rf portal experts conducted laboratory tests of powders for automatic washing machines. Brands of different price categories participated in the examination: Tide White Clouds, Ariel mountain spring”, “Myth 3 in 1 frosty freshness”, “Persil Expert”, “Pemos oxygen crystals” and “Dosia alpine freshness”.

Warning - toxic!

The most dangerous components of washing powder are phosphates and anionic surfactants (A-surfactants). Anionic surfactants can cause allergies and immune disorders, adversely affect skin cells, and in high concentrations can affect the liver, kidneys, lungs, nervous system. The worst thing is that surfactants can accumulate in our body.

The presence of phosphates in the powder is primarily dangerous for environment where sooner or later they will get wastewater from the washing machine - they irreversibly destroy the ecosystems of water bodies. Therefore, the whole world is striving for their ban in the composition of laundry detergents. It is also believed that phosphate additives can enhance the adverse effects of anionic surfactants. Phosphates contribute to the accumulation of these substances in the fibers of the fabric from which clothing is made, enhance the penetration of surfactants through the skin and, according to some reports, even lead to a violation of the properties of the blood. Wool and cotton fabrics hold A-surfactants best of all. And even after 10-fold rinsing in warm water chemicals remain in the fibers of the fabric.

To find out how dangerous each powder is to health, experts determined the toxicity index. To do this, the powder is diluted in water in a certain way and live cells - bovine spermatozoa - are placed in the resulting solution. The faster the cells die, the more toxic, that is, in fact, poisonous, the powder is.

The worst indicators of toxicity are in Pemos and Ariel powders, which means that they contain the most substances hazardous to health.

Slightly better toxicity indicators for powders "Tide white clouds" and "Myth 3 in 1". The manufacturers of these products indicated on the label that the powders are suitable, including for children's underwear. The examination showed: they are too toxic, and in no case should they be used for washing children's clothes!

What matters is how much harmful substances remain in the laundry after washing. Experts have determined the residual amount of anionic and nonionic surfactants in the water after washing and the third rinse. It turned out that most anionic surfactants remain in water (and hence in linen) after washing with Ariel powder.

Least of all A-surfactants remained in the water after washing with Dosia powder.

Irina Konokhova, expert of the portal Roskontrol.rf, doctor: « Washing powder is never 100% washed out of the fabric, and its components remain on linen and clothes. Children are more sensitive to the influence of harmful components of the powder. If these substances have a local irritating or sensitizing effect, then in contact with a fabric washed with such a powder, irritation, redness, itching, peeling, an allergic reaction may appear on the child's skin, and the penetration of toxic substances through the skin can lead to dysfunction of internal organs. The same reactions can occur in adults.».

What to do?

To reduce negative impact harmful components of washing powder experts recommend repeated rinsing of laundry. It is very important to take precautions: do not touch the powder with your hands, keep containers with detergents out of the reach of children, tightly close the opened package and do not inhale the washing powder when you put it in the machine. Inhalation of powder dust leads to the destruction of the surfactant - the film lining the pulmonary alveoli, which can cause the most various diseases lungs.

As you know, advertising is the engine of trade, and the quality of washing powder does not always meet expectations. What are the best tools? How to choose washing powder? Reviews about famous brands- whether to believe them? An overview of popular laundry detergents in this article will help you decide on the choice of powder, as well as dispel a few myths about some products.

Tool Selection: The Basics

When buying a powder, the following nuances are important:

Chemical composition;

Price;

The presence of allergic reactions;

Type of washing;

type of washing machine;

The origin of the stains to be removed.

The task is greatly complicated by factors such as:

excessive wide choose detergents;

Fake;

Regular changes in the main composition;

Features of operation.

Classification of washing powders

1. With the presence of biological additives.
2. Designed to remove contaminants.
3. Designed for whitening.

Some tools may combine the above functions. Their effectiveness is best described, for example, by such reviews: this type of washing powder is quite capricious in “combat” conditions, and under certain circumstances may not be able to cope with the job.

In accordance with the functional qualities, the funds can be conditionally divided into the following large groups and types of pollution:

What is laundry detergent made of?

The principle of operation of any is to dissolve the active substances in water, due to which the process of hydrolysis begins - the splitting of solid starting elements with the subsequent emergence of new compounds, otherwise - foam. Thus the erasure begins. The foam collects dirt from the fabric and absorbs its particles.